÷ƒ’À; è TeX output 2019.04.13:2243‹ ÿÿÿÿŸö¹í‘¹íïhtml:ïcolor push gray 0ï color popï html:ŽŽ¥½Æà ýB9 ïŽ! /pgfH{/pgfheight exch def 0.75 setlinewidth [] 0 setdash /pgfshade {pgfA} def /pgfdir { dup 0 moveto dup 5 index lineto } bind def} bind defï˜! /pgfV{/pgfheight exch def 0.75 setlinewidth [] 0 setdash /pgfshade {pgfA} def /pgfdir { dup 0 exch moveto dup 5 index exch lineto } bind def} bind defò ›! /pgfA{ /pgfdiff 8 index round cvi 8 index round cvi sub 2 mul 1 add def 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div pgfheight 9 index 9 index 9 index 14 index pgfdiff { 3 index 3 index 3 index setrgbcolor pgfdir stroke 4 -1 roll 7 index add 4 -1 roll 6 index add 4 -1 roll 5 index add 4 -1 roll .5 sub } repeat mark 15 1 roll cleartomark exch pop }bind def ò "! /pgfR1{ newpath dup dup dup 0 360 arc clip newpath dup /pgfendx exch def /pgfendy exch def 0.875 setlinewidth [] 0 setdash /pgfshade {pgfR} def /pgfstartx exch def /pgfstarty exch def /pgfdiffx pgfendx pgfstartx sub def /pgfdiffy pgfendy pgfstarty sub def dup /pgfdomb exch def }bind def ï]! /pgfR2{ newpath 0.5 add pgfcircx pgfcircy 3 2 roll 0 360 arc setrgbcolor fill pop}bind def ò X! /pgfR{ /pgfdiff 8 index round cvi 8 index round cvi sub 4 mul 1 add def /pgfcircx pgfstartx 9 index pgfdiffx pgfdomb div mul add def /pgfcircy pgfstarty 9 index pgfdiffy pgfdomb div mul add def /pgfcircxe pgfstartx 8 index pgfdiffx pgfdomb div mul add def /pgfcircye pgfstarty 8 index pgfdiffy pgfdomb div mul add def /pgfxstep pgfcircxe pgfcircx sub pgfdiff div def /pgfystep pgfcircye pgfcircy sub pgfdiff div def 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div 2 index 6 index sub pgfdiff div 8 index 8 index 8 index 13 index pgfdiff { 3 index 3 index 3 index setrgbcolor pgfcircx pgfcircy 2 index 0 360 arc closepath stroke 4 -1 roll 6 index add 4 -1 roll 5 index add 4 -1 roll 4 index add 4 -1 roll .25 sub /pgfcircx pgfcircx pgfxstep add def /pgfcircy pgfcircy pgfystep add def } repeat mark 14 1 roll cleartomark exch pop }bind defò m! /pgfsc{}bind def/pgffc{}bind def/pgfstr{stroke}bind def/pgffill{fill}bind def/pgfeofill{eofill}bind def/pgfe{a dup 0 rlineto exch 0 exch rlineto neg 0 rlineto closepath}bind def/pgfw{setlinewidth}bind def/pgfs{save pgfpd 72 Resolution div 72 VResolution div neg scale magscale{1 DVImag div dup scale}if pgfx neg pgfy neg translate pgffoa .setopacityalpha}bind def/pgfr{pgfsd restore}bind def userdict begin/pgfo{pgfsd /pgfx currentpoint /pgfy exch def def @beginspecial}bind def /pgfc{newpath @endspecial pgfpd}bind def /pgfsd{globaldict /pgfdelta /delta where {pop delta} {0} ifelse put}bind def/pgfpd{/delta globaldict /pgfdelta get def}bind def /.setopacityalpha where {pop} {/.setopacityalpha{pop}def} ifelse /.pgfsetfillopacityalpha{/pgffoa exch def /pgffill{gsave pgffoa .setopacityalpha fill 1 .setopacityalpha newpath fill grestore newpath}bind def /pgfeofill{gsave pgffoa .setopacityalpha eofill 1 .setopacityalpha newpath eofill grestore newpath}bind def}bind def /.pgfsetstrokeopacityalpha{/pgfsoa exch def /pgfstr{gsave pgfsoa .setopacityalpha stroke grestore newpath}bind def}bind def /pgffoa 1 def /pgfsoa 1 def end Žï!papersize=597.50787pt,845.04684ptï!papersize=597.50787pt,845.04684pt¡ ýEô‘ºâïcolor push gray 0’‹‚ï color popŽŽ œþ‘ºâ ý|ôïcolor push gray 0ï! /pgf1{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw 2.00002 0.0 moveto -6.00006 4.00005 lineto -3.00003 0.0 lineto -6.00006 -4.00005 lineto pgffill grestore} bind defïé! /pgf2{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw 0.8 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash 1 setlinecap 1 setlinejoin -3.00003 4.00005 moveto -2.75002 2.50002 0.0 0.24998 0.75 0.0 curveto 0.0 -0.24998 -2.75002 -2.50002 -3.00003 -4.00005 curveto pgfstr grestore} bind defïm! /pgf3{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash 0.0 -5.00005 moveto 0.0 5.00005 lineto pgfstr grestore} bind defïž! /pgf4{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash -3.00003 -5.00005 moveto 0.0 -5.00005 lineto 0.0 5.00005 lineto -3.00003 5.00005 lineto pgfstr grestore} bind defï‘! /pgf5{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash -2.00002 -5.00005 moveto 1.0 -3.00003 1.0 3.00003 -2.00002 5.00005 curveto pgfstr grestore} bind defïŠ! /pgf6{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash -4.50003 -5.00005 moveto 0.49998 0.0 lineto -4.50003 5.00005 lineto pgfstr grestore} bind defò Ž! /pgf7{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw -2.50002 0.0 translate [ ] 0.0 setdash 3.00003 0.0 moveto 3.00003 1.65689 1.65689 3.00003 0.0 3.00003 curveto -1.65689 3.00003 -3.00003 1.65689 -3.00003 0.0 curveto -3.00003 -1.65689 -1.65689 -3.00003 0.0 -3.00003 curveto 1.65689 -3.00003 3.00003 -1.65689 3.00003 0.0 curveto closepath gsave pgffc pgffill grestore gsave pgfsc pgfstr grestore newpath grestore} bind defïß! /pgf8{gsave exec 1.0 pgfw [ ] 0.0 setdash 1.0 0.0 moveto -5.00005 3.00003 lineto -11.00012 0.0 lineto -5.00005 -3.00003 lineto closepath gsave pgffc pgffill grestore gsave pgfsc pgfstr grestore newpath grestore} bind defïhtml:ï html:Ÿ ¡è‘JŠoïcolor push gray 0ï color popŽŽ‘P ójmÐY G® G® ec-lmr17ÇEnqu€ête–7vsur“les“mosŽdes“d'existenceŽŸ ‘p“des–7v€êtres“math€ématiquesŽŸÖ)’ ¢Ü‡ïcolor push gray 0ï color popŽŽ’ ¨V!óO(½! ec-lmr12ÈGuy‘ê§W‘ÿValletŽ©|æ‘Mpïó® ó3 ec-lmr10ÆLabMÞoratoire–¦fmath€ématiques,“image“et“applicationsŽ¤ ™š’ ˆD=Univš²!ersit€é–¦fde“La“RoMÞc˜helleŽ¡‘=ýN23›¦fa•²!v“en“ue˜Alb•MÞert˜Einstein,˜BP˜33060,˜17031˜La˜Ro“c²!helleŽ¡’ ŒD@ï$html:ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0óÔ¢Y ó3 ec-lmtt10Éguy.wallet@gmail.comï html:ï color popŽŸ1£’ –Wïcolor push gray 0ï color popŽŽ’ ›Ð¶ÈStefan‘ê§Neu¬qwirthŽ¦‘\¹¿ÆLabMÞoratoire–¦fde“math€ématiques“de“Besan€çonŽ¡‘lßUnivš²!ersit€é–¦fBourgogne“F‘ÿfranc˜he-Com˜t€éŽ¡‘cZ¨16–¦froute“de“Gra²!y‘ÿf,“25030“Besan€çon“CedexŽ¡‘ojªï.html:ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0Éstefan.neuwirth@univ-‘ € fcomte.frï html:ï color popŽŸ<·´’ ¬qïcolor push gray 0ï color popŽŽ’ ±êœó*&ï· ec-lmbx10ÕR€ésum€éŽŸNÒ‘ ïcolor push gray 0‘æjï color popŽŽ‘*`ó)® ec-lmr10ÔL'obGjet–a¯de“cet“essai“est“l'accueil‘a®des“enš¸ãtit€és“math€ématiques“dans“l'arc˜hitec-Ž¤ ‘`ture–ddes›cmoGdes“d'existence˜propGos€ée“par˜Bruno“Latour˜dans“le˜cadre“de˜sonŽ¡‘`onš¸ãtologie–'pluraliste“du“monde“moGderne“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:Latourï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:2012ï html:ï color pop].‘HLes“tra˜v‘ÿqÇaux“de“RevielŽ¡‘`Netz–4sur“l'€émergence“des“math€ématiques“grecques“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:Netzï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:1999ï html:ï color pop]“et“de“CharlesŽ¡‘`Sanders–5›P¸ãeirce›5šsur“la˜dimension“diagrammatique“de˜l'activit€é“math€ématiqueŽ¡‘`[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:P•¸ãeirceï html:ï color pop›¤sïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:1933-1958ï html:ï color pop],‘¤¡[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:P“eirceï html:ï color pop˜ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:1976ï html:ï color pop]˜son“t˜emplo“y“€és˜p•Gour˜prop“oser˜une˜r€ép“onse˜dansŽ¡‘`le–`êcadre›`ëd'une“conception˜empirique“des“math€ématiques˜bas€ée“sur˜la“notionŽ¡‘`d'expG€érience–ãc¸ãh€ère›ä€à“William“James“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:Jamesï html:ï color pop˜ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:2005ï html:ï color pop]“et“inspir€ée“par˜certains“as-Ž¡‘`pšGects–æde“la‘æ~philosophie“de“P¸ãer“Martin-L€öf“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:Martin-L€öfï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:1987ï html:ï color pop].‘ç]Cette“appro˜c¸ãheŽ¡‘`p•Germet›ãºde‘ã¹p“enser˜la˜solide˜certitude–ã¹don¸ãt˜la˜d€émonstration˜dote“les˜r€ésultatsŽ¡‘`math€ématiques–2Ïtout›2Îen“in•¸ãv‘ÿqÇalidan“t˜son‘2Ïin“terpr€étation˜comme–2Ïla˜marque“d'unŽ¡‘`acc€ès–UUdirect“€à“une“vš¸ã€érit€é“absolue“et“transcendan˜te.ŽŸ¢Ý’ ªo)ïcolor push gray 0ï color popŽŽ’ ¯èÃÕAbstractŽŸ9‘*`ÔThis–=essaš¸ãy‘= inquires“ho˜w“mathematical“bšGeings‘= could“b˜e“inserted“in¸ãto‘= the“ar-Ž¡‘`c¸ãhitecture–¬`of›¬amoGdes“of˜existence“propGosed˜b¸ãy“Bruno˜Latour“in˜the“framew¸ãorkŽ¡‘`of–ÇÕhis›ÇÔpluralist“and˜renewš¸ãed“on˜tology›ÇÔof“the˜moGdern“w¸ãorld˜[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:Latourï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:2012ï html:ï color pop].‘È„AnŽ¡‘`answ¸ãer–Ñis›Ñ¬propGosed“with“the˜aid“of“the˜w¸ãork“of“Reviel˜Netz“on“the˜emergence“ofŽ¡‘`Greek–ÙÍmathematics“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:Netzï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:1999ï html:ï color pop],‘Ùìand“of“Charles“Sanders“P¸ãeirce“on“the“diagram-Ž¡‘`matic–7dimension›7Œof“mathematical“practice˜[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:Pš¸ãeirceï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:1933-1958ï html:ï color pop],‘7”[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:P˜eirceï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:1976ï html:ï color pop],‘7”inŽ¡‘`the–êÛframew¸ãork›êÚof“an“empiric˜conception“of“mathematics˜based“on“the˜notion“ofŽ¡‘`expGerience–¨¹according“to“William“James“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:Jamesï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:2005ï html:ï color pop],‘¨Ïand“inspired“b¸ãy“certainŽ¡‘`aspšGects–&íof‘&ìP¸ãer“Martin-L€öf˜'s›&ìphilosoph¸ãy“[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:Martin-L€öfï html:ï color pop˜ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï!html:1987ï html:ï color pop].‘'4It˜pro¸ãvides“a˜w•¸ãa“y‘&íofŽ¡‘`describing–½uthe›½trm“certain•¸ãt“y‘½uwith˜whic“h‘½uproGofs˜endo“w–½utheorems,‘½while“in¸ãv‘ÿqÇali-Ž¡‘`dating–W|the›W{in¸ãterpretation“of“this˜certain•¸ãt“y–W|as“the˜mark“of˜a“direct“access˜to“anŽ¡‘`absolute–UUand“transcenden¸ãtal“truth.ŽŽŸ ‘ºâïcolor push gray 0’ Ã6Æ1Ž’‹‚ï color popŽŽŽŒ‹ *Ÿö¹í‘¹íïhtml:ïcolor push gray 0ï color popï html:ŽŽ ½Æà ýEô‘ºâïcolor push gray 0’‹‚ï color popŽŽ œþ‘ºâ ý|ôïhtml:ï html:© ó,q2 ff ec-lmbx12×1Ž‘LËInŒÌtros3ductionŽŸq‘ ÆD€ésign€ée–ê8par“l'abr€éviation‘þvó-¨Š| ó3 ec-lmcsc10Øeme“Ædans“la“suite“de“ce“texte,‘êil'ó.Ĉ:- ó3 ec-lmri10ÙEnqu€ête–=Ìsur“les“mo‘ÿp¹desŽ¤ ™š‘ÿ)d'existenc‘ÿp¹e‘ð%Æest–‹Ú€à›‹Ûla“fois˜le“livre˜[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:Latourï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ï html:2012ï html:ï color pop]˜et“le˜site“participatif˜[ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:Latourï html:ï color pop“ïcolor push rgb 1 0 0ïhtml:2013ï html:ï color pop].Ž¡Ils–ÖpropMÞosen²!t›Õde“revisiter“le“c€÷ur˜de“notre“moMÞdernit€é˜“sciences,‘îtec²!hniques,‘ídroit,Ž¡religion,–